Comparing Policies
The key questions to ask and factors to weigh when evaluating pet insurance options.
Questions to Ask When Comparing
Not all pet insurance policies are equal. Premiums can look similar, but the actual value varies enormously based on what is covered, what is excluded, and how claims are calculated. Here are the key questions to work through:
-
What is the annual limit, and are there sub-limits per condition?
-
What is the excess amount, and is it per-claim, per-condition, or annual?
-
What is the benefit percentage? Is it applied after or before excess?
-
What are the waiting periods for accidents, illness, cruciate, and dental?
-
How does the policy define pre-existing conditions? Is there a pathway for temporary pre-existing conditions to become covered?
-
Are there breed-specific exclusions that apply to my pet?
-
Does the policy cover ongoing/chronic conditions in subsequent years, or does cover reset each renewal?
-
How do premiums increase with age? Is there an age cap beyond which the pet cannot be insured or renewed?
-
Does the policy cover specialist and referral hospital costs?
-
Is there a multi-pet discount?
One of the most important differences between policies is how they handle ongoing or chronic conditions at renewal. Some policies continue to cover a condition once it is accepted. Others reset the condition limit each year or exclude it as pre-existing at renewal. For pets with chronic conditions like allergies, arthritis, or diabetes, this distinction can make a difference of thousands of dollars.
Comparing Apples with Apples
When comparing two or more policies, the most meaningful comparison is to estimate what you would receive in a real claim scenario.
Example scenario: Your dog needs cruciate ligament surgery costing $5,000.
Policy A: $200 excess, 80% benefit, no sub-limit - Insurer pays: 80% of ($5,000 - $200) = $3,840 - You pay: $1,160
Policy B: $0 excess, 70% benefit, $3,000 sub-limit on orthopaedic - Insurer pays: 70% of $5,000 = $3,500, but capped at $3,000 sub-limit - You pay: $2,000
Policy A has a higher benefit percentage and no sub-limit, so despite the $200 excess, the payout is significantly better for expensive treatments. Policy B’s $0 excess sounds attractive but the sub-limit caps the real value.
Run through scenarios relevant to your pet’s breed and age — cruciate surgery, cancer treatment, an emergency foreign body removal — and see what each policy would actually pay.
Policy Comparison Steps
Put these steps in a logical order for comparing pet insurance policies.